Warning: Undefined variable $custom_meta_html in /home/u708958881/domains/myvatcalculator.eu/public_html/wp-content/themes/astra-child/header.php on line 26
New VAT Exemption: Sales of Goods Act Excludes Service Tax for Non-Goods Transportation - My Vat Calculator

New VAT Exemption: Sales of Goods Act Excludes Service Tax for Non-Goods Transportation

"CESTAT Ruling: Effluent Not Classified as 'Good' under Sales of Goods Act"

CESTAT, Ahmedabad, in the case of M/s Panoli Enviro Technology Limited v. Commissioner of Central Excise & ST, SURAT-II, has made a significant ruling regarding the classification of effluent under the Sales of Goods Act, 1930 and its inclusion in the Goods Transport Agency (GTA) service for the purpose of service tax. The decision, dated July 07, 2023, states that effluent does not qualify as a ‘good’ under the Sales of Goods Act and therefore, its transportation by GTA is exempt from service tax.

This ruling has far-reaching implications for industries involved in the transportation of effluent and the taxation applicable to such services. The case was brought before the CESTAT, Ahmedabad by M/s Panoli Enviro Technology Limited, challenging the service tax imposed on the transportation of effluent by GTA. The company argued that effluent cannot be considered a ‘good’ under the Sales of Goods Act and, therefore, should not be subject to service tax.

The CESTAT, after careful consideration of the arguments presented, agreed with M/s Panoli Enviro Technology Limited’s contention. The Sales of Goods Act defines ‘goods’ as any kind of movable property, including actionable claims, stocks, and shares. However, the Act does not specifically mention effluent as falling within this definition. Therefore, the CESTAT concluded that effluent does not qualify as a ‘good’ under the Sales of Goods Act.

The CESTAT also examined the definition of Goods Transport Agency (GTA) as per the service tax regulations. The GTA service is applicable to the transportation of ‘goods.’ Since effluent does not fall within the definition of ‘goods,’ the transportation of effluent by GTA is not covered under the ambit of service tax.

This ruling provides much-needed clarity on the taxation of effluent transportation services. Many industries, such as chemical plants, pharmaceutical companies, and wastewater treatment facilities, rely on GTA services for the transportation of effluent. The exemption from service tax will undoubtedly be a welcome relief for these industries, as it will reduce their operational costs and provide a boost to their overall competitiveness.

Moreover, this ruling aligns with the government’s efforts to promote sustainable practices and environmental conservation. By exempting the transportation of effluent from service tax, the government encourages industries to adopt responsible waste management practices and invest in eco-friendly solutions.

It is important to note that this ruling applies specifically to the transportation of effluent by GTA and does not extend to other forms of waste or waste management services. Industries involved in the transportation of other forms of waste should consult with tax professionals to determine the applicability of service tax to their specific operations.

Overall, the decision of the CESTAT, Ahmedabad in the case of M/s Panoli Enviro Technology Limited v. Commissioner of Central Excise & ST, SURAT-II brings much-needed clarity to the classification of effluent under the Sales of Goods Act and its inclusion in the GTA service for the purpose of service tax. This ruling will have a positive impact on industries involved in the transportation of effluent, reducing their tax burden and promoting sustainable waste management practices.

Barry Caldwell

Barry Caldwell

Leave a Replay

Recent Posts

Sign up for VAT News Updates

Click edit button to change this text. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit